Luxury with a Family Touch

It’s not just a promise. It’s our passion.

Kay’s Fine Jewelry was founded on a promise to deliver Luxury with a Family Touch. From day one, this meant anyone who walked into our island stores immediately became part of the family and that’s how they were treated. This is still true today and we have plenty of customers happy to tell you as much.

Now we’re expanding our promise even further with the introduction of the Kay’s Fine Jewelry online store. Now you can shop our collection of diamonds, gemstones and custom design jewelry from the comfort of your own home and still enjoy our amazing duty-free pricing.

Arlene and Robert Baxt from Maryland

Jason and Linda Pouliot from NH!

Marylou & Carmen Calleri from PA

Marylou Calleri & Carmen Calleri from PA

Terry & James Todd from MD with Tesh

50th Birthday celebration for Carolyn Starman

50th Birthday celebration in Kay_s fine Jewelry St. Maarten for Carolyn Starman from Seattle with Bob

Amy Toye and family from NY!

Ceredeo, Flagg, Parsell, Palladino, family from NH

Connie and John Livers

David and Mary Pink from Phildelphia

Happy Wife Happy Life

Mark, Martha, John, Kevin from Houston, Texas!

Shimanskas family from FL

Susan, Charles and Jan from Holly Springs, North Carolina

Tony in St. Kitts

Kent and Jennifer from PA

Jaye and David from MD

Jami Entas and sue Entas from IA

Emily and Jeff from TX

The Marinelli’s from Long Island

Barbara and Louise from Chicago

Sue and Jack from CA

Gerken Family from NJ

Mr. Richard Finlay and Ms. Dionne shop at our KFJ NAS store

From MARS, PA to St. Thomas

Beyond Satisfied

Susan D. Cincinnati, Ohio (TripAdvisor)

Kay's Fine Jewelry truly distinguishes themselves from all other jewelers! The selection is always current -- with great variety of items and price ranges. If they don't have what you want --let them know --they have done some great custom pieces for us. We have been customers for years because they CONTINUE TO EARN our loyal with the quality of product, price value and professional staff. We not only believe they are the best on the island but they get our best overall --they are our jeweler of choice! try them out and we are sure you will agree

"Trusted Friends"

Peggy C. Berwyn, Pennsylvania (TripAdvisor)

We have been shopping at Kay's for the last 8 years while on our annual vacations to Aruba. Friends at our timeshare recommended Kay's, and they were absolutely right! Kay's is a family owned business, and we genuinely feel like one of the family. The quality of the jewelry and the level of service are truly unsurpassed. Joe, Tesh, Ash and everyone at Kay's are the best!

Always "something " special

Beth K. (TripAdvisor)

Our family goes to Aruba every year. A visit to Kay’s is just like saying hello to our Aruban family. Always treated very well. Never pushed. My husband and I are always happy with our purchases. The "family " stays in touch all year! I know if I need anything (gift or repair) I can just send a message. 10 stars to my Kay’s family!

Distinctive Jewelry Store - exceptional service!

stepmor99 Burlington, CT (TripAdvisor)

I was looking for a certain style of a Tanzanite ring to match a set of earrings that I purchased a few years ago at another store in the Caribbean. Kay's did not have the exact style that I was looking for in that stone. However, they were able to take an emerald ring and replace the emerald with a beautiful Tanzanite stone of deep color and clarity, perfectly matching my earrings. The price was exceptional and the service was great. As I waited for my new ring to be crafted and sized (less than an hour...), I noticed many return customers coming into the store. They were greeted like long lost family. I will be back for sure!

They will make it happen

Carmen C Bloomsburg, Pennsylvania (TripAdvisor)

My wife wanted a ring she saw on Kay’s Facebook page. But she wanted it with purple diamonds and a rose gold setting. Even though they didn’t have anything like that in stock, they are now making it for her special. It will be a one-of-a-kind just for her. This is how they treat their customers, like they are family members. Harry and Uncle Joe are our go-to guys, but everyone there is so friendly and helpful.